[devel] IQ: Samba 3.2.0-pre1 is coming, QT applications are incompatible, remedy plan

[Igor Zubkov]

27.09.07, Alexander Bokovoy написал(а):
> 2. xmms2 доступна под двумя основными лицензиями: LGPLv2.1 и GPLv2.
> Полный список лицензий и файлов, к которым они относятся, можно увидеть
> здесь:
> http://git.xmms.se/?p=xmms2-stable.git;a=blob_plain;h=5d1a621f14418cfb7ecd7ca3eebd2d7b0ea898ff;f=COPYING
> Проблема в том, что в отличие от типичного указания лицензий, в xmms2 не
>   говорится, что действует лицензия A версии X или любая ее последующая
> версия, что означает, что используется только та версия, которая указана
> в распространяемом архиве. Это означает (формально), что libsmbclient не
> может быть слинкован с xmms2 в единое целое. Я прошу мейнтейнера пакета
> выяснить статус применяемых лицензий.

Выяснил. Итого:
1) Библиотеки из xmms2  лицензированы как LGPLv2.1 or later
2) Сам демон xmms2 тоже лицензированы как LGPLv2.1 or later
3) Плагин для работы с smb лицензирован как LGPLv2.1 or later

Т.е. в данной части всё чисто.

Вот COPYING из последнего релиза xmms2 (у нас в Сизифе предпоследний) и вопросы:

>[icesik на iceberg xmms2-0.2DrJekyll]$ cat COPYING
>All the code is "Copyright (C) 2003-2007 XMMS2 Team" and is licensed
>under the GNU Lesser General Public License (LGPL) except the files
>listed below. The full LGPL license text is available in COPYING.LGPL.

Вот собственно где указано что это LGPL. Только здесь не указано что
это 2.1 or later. Это указано в исходниках.

>IMPORTANT! Plugins do NOT constitute derived work, they are just using
>XMMS2 as a library! This means that you can add a non open source
>plugin to your distribution of XMMS2. As developer you AGREE to this
>when you add code to the XMMS2 codebase.
>
>For information about individual contributors look at AUTHORS file.
>
>-----
>
>This should be a complete list of exeptions to the "XMMS2 Team"
>copyright and LGPL license. The full GPL license text is available in
>COPYING.GPL
>
>README, INSTALL:
>        Licensed under GFDL without unmodifiable sections.

Ну это нормально.

>manpages (src/clients/cli/xmms2.1, src/clients/et/xmms2-et.1,
>          src/clients/launcher/xmms2-launcher.1,
>          src/clients/mdns/avahi/xmms2-mdns-avahi.1,
>          src/xmms/xmms2d.1):
>        Licensed under BSD license

Это тоже нормально.

>src/plugins/mad/*.[ch]:
>        Licensed under GPL license.

В загаловках указано что GPLv2 or later.

>src/plugins/mad/xing.c:
>        Uses code base on/copied from madplay:
>        Copyright (C) 2000-2004 Robert Leslie

Но слова я там не нашёл по поводу Robert Leslie. Просто GPLv2 or later.

>src/plugins/mp4/mp4.c:
>        Licensed under GPL license.

GPLv2 or later.

>src/plugins/mp4/mp4ff/drms*:
>        Copyright (C) 2004 VideoLAN
>        Licensed under GPL license.

GPLv2 or later.

>src/plugins/mp4/mp4ff/mp4*:
>        Copyright (C) 2003-2004 M. Bakker, Ahead Software AG, http://www.nero.com
>        Licensed under GPL license.

Указано GPLv2 or later и вот такая дурь:
** Any non-GPL usage of this software or parts of this software is strictly
** forbidden.
**
** Commercial non-GPL licensing of this software is possible.
** For more info contact Ahead Software through Mpeg4AAClicense на nero.com.

>src/plugins/sid/*:
>        Licensed under GPL license.

Вот тут достаточно интересно получается...

sid.c -- GPLv2 or later
sidplay_wrapper.cpp -- без копирайт-кладжа.
sidplay_wrapper.h -- LPGLv2 or later

>src/plugins/sid/md5.*:
>        Copyright (C) 1999 Aladdin Enterprises.

/*
 * This code has been derived by Michael Schwendt <mschwendt на yahoo.com>
 * from original work by L. Peter Deutsch <ghost на aladdin.com>.
 *
 * The original C code (md5.c, md5.h) is available here:
 * ftp://ftp.cs.wisc.edu/ghost/packages/md5.tar.gz
 */

/*
  Copyright (C) 1999 Aladdin Enterprises.  All rights reserved.

  This software is provided 'as-is', without any express or implied
  warranty.  In no event will the authors be held liable for any damages
  arising from the use of this software.

  Permission is granted to anyone to use this software for any purpose,
  including commercial applications, and to alter it and redistribute it
  freely, subject to the following restrictions:

  1. The origin of this software must not be misrepresented; you must not
     claim that you wrote the original software. If you use this software
     in a product, an acknowledgment in the product documentation would be
     appreciated but is not required.
  2. Altered source versions must be plainly marked as such, and must not be
     misrepresented as being the original software.
  3. This notice may not be removed or altered from any source distribution.

  L. Peter Deutsch
  ghost на aladdin.com
 */


>src/plugins/equalizer/eq.c:
>        Licensed under GPL license.

GPLv2 or later

>src/plugins/equalizer/iir*:
>        Copyright (C) 2002-2006 Felipe Rivera <liebremx на users.sourceforge.net>
>        Licensed under GPL license.

GPLv2 or later.

>src/plugins/vocoder/vocoder.c:
>        Licensed under GPL license.

GPLv2 or later.

>src/plugins/vocoder/pvocoder*:
>        Copyright (C) 2006 Juho Vц╓hц╓-Herttua <juhovh на iki.fi>
>        Licensed under GPL license.

GPLv2 or later.

>src/plugins/ices/encode.*:
>        Copyright (c) 2001 Michael Smith <msmith на labyrinth.net.au>
>        Licensed under GPL license.

GPLv2. Без "or later".

>src/plugins/jack/jack.c:
>        Copyright (C) 2004  Chris Morgan <cmorgan на alum.wpi.edu>

LGPLv2 or later.

>src/plugins/daap/daap_md5.*:
>        Copyright (C) 2004,2005 Charles Schmidt <cschmidt2 на emich.edu>
>        Licensed under GPL license.
>        Uses code base on/copied from libopendaap:
>        Copyright (c) 2004 David Hammerton

GPLv2 or later.

>src/plugins/daap/*:
>        Licensed under GPL license.

GPLv2 or later.

>src/includepriv/xmmspriv/xmms_list.h:
>        Copyright (C) 1995-1997  Peter Mattis, Spencer Kimball and Josh MacDonald

LGPLv2 or later.

>src/xmms/bindata.c:
>        Partially: Copyright (C) 1999, 2000, 2002 Aladdin Enterprises.  All rights reserved.
>        Licensed under BSD license.

А в заголовке указано LGPLv2.1 or later.

>wafadmin/:
>        Copyright (C) 2005 Thomas Nagy
>        Licensed under BSD license.
>
>wafadmin/libtool_config.py:
>        Copyright (C) 2006  Matthias Jahn <jahn.matthias на freenet.de>
>
>wafadmin/pproc.py:
>        Copyright (C) 2003-2004 by Peter Astrand <astrand на lysator.liu.se>

Это просто сборочная система. С этими файлами всё в порядке.

>[icesik на iceberg xmms2-0.2DrJekyll]$

-- 
icesik